Buffalo Nickel Value (1913–1938)
Quick answer: Dateless buffalo nickels are worth 30–50 cents. Common dates with readable dates: $1–$5 circulated. Key dates (1913-S Type 2, 1926-S, 1937-D 3-leg): $100–$1,500+.
The buffalo nickel is America’s most iconic coin design — and one where the date literally makes the difference. The date was struck on a raised area that wore away quickly, which is why so many survivors are "dateless." A readable date multiplies the value; a mint mark (under FIVE CENTS on the reverse) can multiply it again.
The famous 1937-D "three-legged" buffalo — created when a mint worker polished off the animal’s foreleg — is one of the most beloved error coins in the hobby.
Key dates worth serious money
1913-S Type 2
$300 – $1,000
1926-S
$20 – $4,000 (grade sensitive)
1937-D 3-legged
$500 – $2,500+
1918/7-D overdate
$1,000 – $10,000+
1921-S, 1924-S
$40 – $600
The story behind the coin
James Earle Fraser modeled the obverse on three Native American chiefs and the reverse on Black Diamond, a bison at the Central Park Zoo. Struck 1913–1938, the design proved so popular it returned on gold bullion coins in 2006.
Frequently asked questions
Is a dateless buffalo nickel worthless?
Not quite — they sell for 30–50 cents in bulk for jewelry and crafts. Date-restored coins (using acid) reveal the date but are only worth a small premium over dateless.
Where is the mint mark?
On the reverse, centered below FIVE CENTS. D = Denver, S = San Francisco (both worth more than plain Philadelphia issues).
How do I spot the 3-legged buffalo?
On genuine 1937-D three-leg coins the front foreleg is missing but the hoof remains, and the hind leg shows a moth-eaten look. Heavily counterfeited — authentication recommended.
What’s the most valuable buffalo nickel?
The 1918/7-D overdate in high grade — five figures. Among regular issues, high-grade 1926-S is king.
Related value guides
Values shown are typical retail ranges for the grades described, based on recent dealer and auction pricing. Markets move; exact value depends on grade, variety and eye appeal. This guide is informational and not a formal appraisal.